Today’s new trailer is Last Christmas, a romantic comedy starring Emilia Clarke and Henry Golding as Kate and Tom, an odd couple who fall in love over Christmas to a soundtrack of classic George Michael tunes.

Or do they? Something seems just a wee bit ... off about the relationship between Kate and Tom. They don’t really go on dates. He seems to have a magical ability to bump into her wherever she goes. She talks about a mysterious illness. And he wears the same clothes, including a conspicuous trench coat, in all but one shot.

Watch the trailer and judge for yourself:

If you ask me, all signs point to there being a major twist here. So what is it? Here are my six favorite theories.

Last Christmas opens in theaters on November 8. I can’t wait to find out which one of these theories is correct. There might not be a “twist” at all — but honestly at this point that would be a pretty disappointing outcome. Bring on the heart transplant ghosts!

Gallery — Directors Who Famously Hated Their Movies: